Commentary

The underappreciated opportunity in today's stock market

Looking beneath index returns to understand what’s really going on in the market may matter more now than it has in decades.

Key takeaways

Why have stock correlations fallen to unusually low levels across major equity markets? This reflects an increase in the importance of company-specific fundamentals. Even as a handful of mega-cap stocks continue to drive index returns, performance beneath the surface has become increasingly differentiated. Companies with strong earnings, healthy balance sheets, and durable competitive advantages are being treated differently than those facing slowing growth or elevated debt burdens. For advisors, this may be an opportune time to look beyond headline index returns and reassess whether underperforming holdings remain supported by their underlying fundamentals.

Despite solid returns for much of 2026, investors still face plenty of uncertainties. Elections, geopolitics, interest rates, elevated valuations, concentrated market leadership, and lofty earnings expectations all suggest that headline index returns may tell only part of the story.

The Capital Markets Strategy Team, however, maintains a constructive outlook. We continue to see long-term tailwinds and attractive opportunities in large cap stocks, even if returns look less stellar than they have in the recent past.

An underappreciated reason

Our optimism is driven in part by the fact that stocks are increasingly moving on their own merits, and doing so to a greater degree than at most points over the past three decades.

As Exhibit 1 shows, equity return correlations have fallen across the board over the past five quarters and are now historically low.

Exhibit 1: Stock correlations have declined for major indexes

  • Major U.S. indexes now sit well below their historical average since 1994, placing current correlations in roughly the lowest quartile of observations.
  • Correlations within the Russell Top 200, S&P 500, and Russell Midcap Index all stand at less than half their historical averages.

At first glance, these findings may seem counterintuitive. Market leadership remains highly concentrated, with a relatively small number of mega-cap companies driving a disproportionate share of index returns. Yet beneath the surface, performance across individual stocks has become increasingly differentiated.

The AI trade is a timely example

The recent sell-off in AI names doesn't mean the theme is failing; it means the theme is growing up. Investors are shifting from capex spend to capex ROI, no longer rewarding heavy spending as a signal of conviction, but looking for evidence that it's turning into cash flow. Companies with similar spending plans have seen very different market reactions as a result.

Earnings season reflects the same discipline. Most S&P 500 companies have beaten estimates, but by the narrowest margins since late 2022. Earnings beats have earned muted rewards while disappointments have been punished sharply. This looks more like valuation discipline than a bubble. Bubbles reward every story equally; this market is separating winners from losers on fundamentals.

The midterm election results fit the same theme. A shift in congressional control is unlikely to move all stocks in the same direction; the impact may be uneven across sectors and companies. Historically, the S&P 500 has also tended to post gains in the year after midterms, regardless of which party won, though past performance is no guarantee of future results.

What is driving portfolio performance?

As outcomes become more dispersed, understanding what is driving portfolio performance may become increasingly important. Advisors may want to look beyond index-level returns and evaluate exposures at the factor, sector, and security levels. Earnings quality, balance-sheet strength, competitive positioning, and durable growth may play a larger role in outcomes than they have in recent years.

As dispersion widens within sectors and across the AI supply chain, selectivity matters more than owning a theme or index, strengthening the case for active management.

In particular, advisors may want to take a fresh look at underperforming holdings. In a market increasingly driven by company-specific fundamentals, the key question is not which stocks have lagged, but why?

For advisors seeking additional perspective, portfolio research resources and investment specialists may help identify what broad market performance can sometimes obscure.

Lower stock correlations cannot tell us where markets go next. They do, however, suggest that broad market trends may be becoming a less complete explanation of what’s really going on in the market.